13 NOV 2026 · # The Scopes Trial: The Day Darrow Put Bryan on the Stand — Convicted S1E16
🔍 Welcome back to Convicted. Today, Nate walks you through the Scopes Monkey Trial of July 1925, when defense lawyer Clarence Darrow called prosecution star William Jennings Bryan to the witness stand in Dayton, Tennessee, and cross-examined him on the Bible itself — the most famous exchange in American courtroom history, struck from the record the very next morning.
In this episode we walk through the testimony that turned a small-town trial into a national reckoning: the Butler Act that made teaching evolution a crime, the two most famous lawyers in America facing each other, Darrow's July 20, 1925 examination of Bryan on the courthouse lawn, the verdict the defense asked for, and the aftermath that stretched forty-three years.
⏱️ TIMESTAMPS
00:00 - Cold Open
00:41 - Act 1: The Law and the Town
01:37 - Act 2: The Two Lawyers
03:39 - Act 3: The Examination
07:21 - Act 4: The Verdict
08:17 - Act 5: The Aftermath
09:43 - Close
❓ What happened at the Scopes trial? In July 1925, twenty-four-year-old science teacher John Thomas Scopes stood trial in Dayton, Tennessee, for violating the Butler Act, which banned teaching evolution in public schools. On July 20, 1925, his lawyer Clarence Darrow called the prosecution's William Jennings Bryan to the stand as an expert on the Bible and questioned him on Genesis, including the famous exchange about where Cain got his wife. The jury found Scopes guilty after nine minutes of deliberation and fined him $100 — a verdict Darrow had asked for so the case could be appealed. The Tennessee Supreme Court reversed the conviction in January 1927 on a technicality, and the Butler Act was repealed in 1967.
📋 THE RECORD
- The Butler Act, passed by the Tennessee legislature in the spring of 1925, made it unlawful for a public school teacher to teach any theory denying the divine creation of man as taught in the Bible, punishable by a fine of $100 to $500.
- The trial, State of Tennessee v. John Thomas Scopes, ran July 10–21, 1925, in the Rhea County Courthouse in Dayton, Tennessee, before Judge John T. Raulston. Scopes, 24, was a science teacher and football coach; the case was arranged as a test case with the American Civil Liberties Union.
- William Jennings Bryan, 65, a three-time Democratic nominee for president, served as special counsel for the prosecution. Clarence Darrow, 67, a staunch agnostic who had defended Leopold and Loeb in 1924, led the defense.
- On Monday, July 20, 1925, Darrow called Bryan to the stand as an expert witness on the Bible. The examination, held outdoors on the courthouse lawn because of the heat, lasted more than an hour and a half. All quoted exchanges in this episode are taken verbatim from the published trial transcript.
- On July 21, 1925, Judge Raulston expunged Bryan's testimony from the record, ruling it irrelevant to whether Scopes had violated the Butler Act. Darrow then asked the jury to return a guilty verdict so the case could be appealed; the move also denied Bryan the closing speech he had spent weeks preparing. The jury deliberated nine minutes, found Scopes guilty, and Judge Raulston imposed the minimum $100 fine.
- Bryan died in Dayton on July 26, 1925, five days after the trial ended. In January 1927, the Tennessee Supreme Court upheld the Butler Act but reversed Scopes's conviction, because the Tennessee Constitution required fines over $50 to be set by the jury, not the judge. The Butler Act remained law until the legislature repealed it in May 1967; in 1968 the U.S. Supreme Court struck down a nearly identical Arkansas law in Epperson v. Arkansas.
- Sources: the published Scopes trial transcript (Digital History, University of Houston; Beliefnet; "The Complete Scopes Trial Transcript"); Tennessee Encyclopedia; HISTORY.com; Linda Hall Library.
🔍 KEYWORDS
Scopes trial, Monkey Trial, Clarence Darrow, William Jennings Bryan, John Scopes, Butler Act, Dayton Tennessee, 1925, courtroom testimony, cross-examination, Cain's wife, true crime, legal history
📋 NOTES
Trial testimony and court reporting. No dramatic reenactments, no fictional dialogue — quoted words are from the published trial transcript. A ColoredJuice Podcast Studio production.
Produced with the help of AI, under full human creative supervision. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/convicted--7182314/support.
This Episode is Brought to you by:
🎵 https://share.uppbeat.io/b1d396uc1nke — music for creators
✍️ https://go.willowvoice.com/coloredjuice — your writing partner
🔊 https://try.elevenlabs.io/81wzrb63uxz9 — lifelike AI voiceovers for creators
🎙️ https://noota.cello.so/MfzMQhRASVY — The best transcription and AI Meeting Zoom alternative!
💼 https://www.withmoxie.com?_get=paul64 — invoicing, CRM, projects, expenses, proposals and time tracking for freelancers.
✨ https://get.castmagic.io/l6g5zae3d7g5 — turn audio into content with presets and community prompts.
📡 https://feedpress.com/?affid=35174 — podcast hosting, stats and feed tools for serious podcasters
────────
❤️ Support Convicted!
Supporter Club: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/convicted--7182314/support · Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/cw/hustlestudios